ADA Website Claims Are Rising—Is Your eCommerce Business at Risk?

Lately, the Thorelli firm has been seeing an increase in small but aggressive law firms pursuing
claims of minor violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) against small to midsize
ecommerce businesses. The claims take several forms. Some complaints are filed in federal
and state courts while others are letters that threaten litigation without actually following through
with any court filing. Some are putative class actions and some appear to rely on “test case”
plaintiffs, typically with some degree of visual impairment, who have allegedly been prevented
from making an online purchase due to a lack sufficient coding on the website for the vision
impaired who use available screen reader technology. In total, 3188 of these cases were filed in
2024 alone. The one thing that they all have in common is that they all make an early demand
for a financial settlement that is clearly less than the cost to defend the claim.

Most complaints are filed in New York, Pennsylvania, Florida and California. While federal
complaints filed by civil plaintiffs do not include provisions for money damages, some state laws
do. Some plaintiffs have gotten creative arguing for federal courts to award them a monitoring
fee to make sure that the courts’ orders to remediate are affected.

Recent legal precedents have called into question whether businesses operated entirely on the
internet with no corresponding physical place of business in the US are subject to ADA
regulations at all. At least two federal courts in New York have concluded that a standalone
website is not a “place of public accommodation” as required by the ADA.

Most complaints seek an order that compels the defendant to revise its website to comply with
the international standards of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). Plaintiffs do
seem to test websites for WCAG 2.1 compliance before preparing a complaint. Usually, but not
always, WCAG 2.1 compliance by your website will reduce the risk of an ADA claim.
Unfortunately, there is no official ADA compliance certification process organized by any federal

agency, so a website operator cannot fully insulate itself from the risk of litigation by using any
private, third party certification program.

Even though these ADA claims may look the same, there are differences that may strengthen
your bargaining leverage or support available defenses. At Thorelli, we carefully review the ADA
claims when they come in to improve our clients’ positions and give them the best chance for a
favorable outcome.

We can also discuss preventive measures which may make your website a less interesting
target. As an example, some eCommerce sites are publishing their own ADA accessibility policy
statement. Others solicit disabled users to provide ADA access audits. A modest investment up
front may save you the hassle of later litigation. Call us to discuss your ADA claim needs.